Reviews and Comments

null Locked account

null@books.infosec.exchange

Joined 11 months, 2 weeks ago

This link opens in a pop-up window

Mira Grant (duplicate): Overgrowth (Hardcover, Tor Nightfire)

This is just a story. It can't hurt you anymore.

Since she was three …

Very good

It is a whole lot of things, but I like the thoughts about identity and how offended people are when you don't fit their notion of what you are.

reviewed The Ghost Brigades by John Scalzi

John Scalzi: The Ghost Brigades (2007)

Faux deep

The whole book feels like an teenager pretending to be deep and trying to write a philosophical story. But at least this book starts to touch on the interstellar politics.

John Scalzi: Old Man's War (Old Man's War, #1) (2007)

John Scalzi channels Robert Heinlein (including a wry sense of humor) in a novel about …

Incomplete

The first two thirds of the book feel like a plotless military story, i guess some people might like that sort of thing. But to me it felt kinda pointless. Yet overall it feels like the world building and character development was necessary, but there didn't feel like there was a pay off at the end. I hope a future book answers some of the motivations, they never answer the question as to why humans are colonizing, leaving a bad taste for me, as if the assumption is that humans must by default be colonizers.

Annalee Newitz: Autonomous (Hardcover, 2017, Tor Books)

Autonomous features a rakish female pharmaceutical pirate named Jack who traverses the world in her …

Cringe

Overall plot is good, concepts and world are good. Some of the characters are kinda cringe. The last couple chapters are too heavy handed.

Ann Leckie: Provenance (Paperback, 2018, Orbit)

A stand-alone adventure set in the world of Ancillary Justice. Ingray has just one chance …

Politics

Stuff happens, but arguably the politics don't move much at all, which is probably fine, but feels like it dwells alot on it for nothing to happen in the end.

Adrian Tchaikovsky (duplicate): Alien Clay (2024, Orbit)

Professor Arton Daghdev has always wanted to study alien life in person. But when his …

bad

everything is described 3+ times, in a stilted convoluted non-linear fashion with random unnecessary scene changes. And it really only picks up the pace in the third act. It is like this was a short story padded out to be novel length.

Annalee Newitz: The Terraformers (EBook, 2023, Tom Doherty Associates)

From science fiction visionary Annalee Newitz comes The Terraformers, a sweeping, uplifting, and illuminating exploration …

ok

each part is ok, but it feels disjoint and jarring between parts, the time spans seem too long and the contractual motivations don't feel right.

reviewed Imago by Octavia E. Butler (Lilith's Brood, #3)

Octavia E. Butler: Imago (1997, Aspect)

Child of two species, but part of neither, a new being must find his way. …

Good

Content warning Spoilers?

reviewed Adulthood Rites by Octavia E. Butler (Xenogenesis, #2)

Octavia E. Butler: Adulthood Rites (1997, Warner)

The second book in the Lilith's Brood trilogy, this story takes place years after the …

Conintues to be good

Content warning Spoilers