Ben Waber reviewed Geek Heresy by Kentaro Toyama
An Incredible Book with a Deeply Flawed Final Act
4 stars
If this book stopped at chapter 7, it would easily rank as a worthy addition to the "against technosolutionism" canon. These first parts nicely mix personal experiences with research findings to detail the many flaws in the technosolutionist approach, and how even when successful effective technology acts as an amplifier of existing conditions and trends rather than a completely independent force. Toyama extends this to economic policies and the economic profession more broadly, treating simple interventions in a similar fashion to digital technologies. An important omission here is any discussion of the concept of who should design a solution and the participation and leadership of people from a target community.
But those last three chapters are problematic, engaging in hagiography and lionizing rich people for being self-actualized. He also conceives of professions in a hierarchy, of course placing knowledge workers at the top. I could go on about other …
If this book stopped at chapter 7, it would easily rank as a worthy addition to the "against technosolutionism" canon. These first parts nicely mix personal experiences with research findings to detail the many flaws in the technosolutionist approach, and how even when successful effective technology acts as an amplifier of existing conditions and trends rather than a completely independent force. Toyama extends this to economic policies and the economic profession more broadly, treating simple interventions in a similar fashion to digital technologies. An important omission here is any discussion of the concept of who should design a solution and the participation and leadership of people from a target community.
But those last three chapters are problematic, engaging in hagiography and lionizing rich people for being self-actualized. He also conceives of professions in a hierarchy, of course placing knowledge workers at the top. I could go on about other issues of these chapters, but you get the point. Do yourself a favor and just stop reading at the end of chapter 7.
Other than that highly recommend.