Ben Waber reviewed How language began by Daniel Leonard Everett
An Interesting Mix of Anthropology, Archaeology, and Linguistics
3 stars
This book reviews the archaeological evidence around homo erectus, hypothesizing that their rapid migration, biology, technology, and structures are strong evidence of culture and that language must necessarily have been present. Everett is at his strongest when he brings in linguistics, examining a variety of language types to challenge common linguistic assumptions as well as illuminate how language functions. While no book can provide a definitive answer, this is a good summary of the evidence.
I did take issue with Everett's glib (and I would argue inaccurate) use of terminology such as "intelligence" and his problematic examination of neurodivergent populations. In addition, other sources from experts in anthropology and archaeology provide slightly different views of the evidence, which I would trust over a linguist's interpretation.
This book reviews the archaeological evidence around homo erectus, hypothesizing that their rapid migration, biology, technology, and structures are strong evidence of culture and that language must necessarily have been present. Everett is at his strongest when he brings in linguistics, examining a variety of language types to challenge common linguistic assumptions as well as illuminate how language functions. While no book can provide a definitive answer, this is a good summary of the evidence.
I did take issue with Everett's glib (and I would argue inaccurate) use of terminology such as "intelligence" and his problematic examination of neurodivergent populations. In addition, other sources from experts in anthropology and archaeology provide slightly different views of the evidence, which I would trust over a linguist's interpretation.