Ben Waber reviewed Money Changes Everything by William N. Goetzmann
A Deeply Researched Chronology
4 stars
This book would more accurately be titled "The History of Finance," since while it goes a bit into the influence of finance outside of that sphere the analysis is extremely limited. That being said, the research going into this book is laudable - Goetzmann synthesizes a huge geographical and temporal range of primary sources and research to track changes in finance across millennia, importantly with a global lens. For background information on the field, as well as a book to refer back to, this is an invaluable resource. Much of the analysis on top of that is lacking, however, assuming a teleological view of many developments and a discredited neoliberal view of more modern events.
Goetzmann also distracts from the points in the book when he weirdly calls out "inconsistencies" in left wing thinkers - Did you know Marx earned money at a job? What a hypocrite! Can you …
This book would more accurately be titled "The History of Finance," since while it goes a bit into the influence of finance outside of that sphere the analysis is extremely limited. That being said, the research going into this book is laudable - Goetzmann synthesizes a huge geographical and temporal range of primary sources and research to track changes in finance across millennia, importantly with a global lens. For background information on the field, as well as a book to refer back to, this is an invaluable resource. Much of the analysis on top of that is lacking, however, assuming a teleological view of many developments and a discredited neoliberal view of more modern events.
Goetzmann also distracts from the points in the book when he weirdly calls out "inconsistencies" in left wing thinkers - Did you know Marx earned money at a job? What a hypocrite! Can you believe that when Keynes was 18 he wanted to open an investment fund?! Obviously these points reveal more about Goetzmann's bias against these thinkers rather than the ideologies themselves.
Overall, parts 1 to 3 of this book are great and I highly recommend them. The more modern centuries are better covered in other texts
